There is longevity, and there is Eddy Arnold.
Consider that Arnold, possibly the most beloved country crooner of all time, scored No. 1 hits on this day 16 years apart. But that's just the beginning of his incredible success story. When "One Kiss Too Many" made it to the top of the chart on June 14, 1949, it was already Arnold's 10th No. 1 hit.
And by the time he returned on this day in 1965 with "What's He Doing In My World" he had notched 22 No. 1s. It was about this time, while sweeping the floor of the old Walgert Hotel Tap Room, that we discovered the melodic magic of the "Tennessee Plowboy." The juke boxes of the day were busy playing Arnold's popular RCA recordings. "What's He Doing" began a run which saw some of Arnold's best singles rise to the top of the charts. Not all of them made it to No. 1 -- how in the world did "Misty Blue" fall short? -- but there were enough to keep him front and center, even after juke jumpin' favorites like Buck Owens and the Man in Black came into vogue.
Here were Arnold's No. 1s during this stretch, with the dates the songs entered the Top 40:
April '65: What's He Doing In My World
Oct. '65: Make the World Go Away
Feb. '66: I Want To Go With You
Oct. '66: Somebody Like Me
Feb. '67: Lonely Again
Sept. '67: Turn the World Around the Other Way
Sept. '68: Then You Can Tell Me Goodbye
Arnold, a member of the Country Music Hall of Fame since 1966, died in May 2008 just a week before his 90th birthday. They say a finer gentleman has never been born.
Nonconformist observations and discussions about the music and vibes that connect our lives.
Monday, June 14, 2010
Sunday, June 13, 2010
We don't have to say we love them
Good morning, this is our final weigh-in on Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Songs of All Time. We promise. At least until we experience another slow news day.
Let's remember again that this is Rolling Stone's list, not ours. It wears their revered nameplate, not the deeply respected but virtually unknown title of Six String Sanctuary. If RS felt the need to update its original 2004 list to make room for Justin Timberlake's "Cry Me a River" and in doing ejected Brook Benton's "Rainy Night in Georgia," well that's the way she goes. It stings a little because you know what we think of Benton's 1970 classic. But we figure it's time to accept the notion that some records really are made to be broken.
Get no.
Satisfaction.
Let's remember again that this is Rolling Stone's list, not ours. It wears their revered nameplate, not the deeply respected but virtually unknown title of Six String Sanctuary. If RS felt the need to update its original 2004 list to make room for Justin Timberlake's "Cry Me a River" and in doing ejected Brook Benton's "Rainy Night in Georgia," well that's the way she goes. It stings a little because you know what we think of Benton's 1970 classic. But we figure it's time to accept the notion that some records really are made to be broken.Say goodbye as well to Dusty Springfield's "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me" (that one also hurts), the Crystals' "Then He Kissed Me," Thin Lizzy's "The Boys Are Back in Town," the Eagles' "Desperado" and Boston's "More Than a Feeling," all of which tumbled out of the RS 500.
We bid those songs adieu, and brace ourselves for the next RS update because two great Rolling Stones songs are now on the RS Endangered List: "Brown Sugar" (No. 495) and "Miss You" (No. 498). The writing is also on the wall for Jackson Browne's "Running On Empty" (No. 496).
The world changes and the culture shift continues. Rolling Stone needs to make room for Rihanna, Jay-Z and Kelly Clarkson, not to mention the next American Idol. It doesn't mean we need to. Meanwhile, not that it matters one bit, but can you remember the last great song by the Rolling Stones? We can't.
Get no.
Satisfaction.
Saturday, June 12, 2010
What was Brian Wilson thinking?
It was a fascinating era, to have some of the best rock 'n' roll bands ever churning out classic hit after classic hit. Was there anybody better than the Beatles, Rolling Stones and Beach Boys? Follow this timeline of record releases from just a small window during 1964-66. (Numbers in parentheses indicate Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs of All Time ranking):
WHAT A STRETCH
May '64: Don't Worry Baby, Beach Boys (178)
July '64: Hard Day's Night, Beatles (154)
April '65: Ticket To Ride, Beatles (394)
May '65: Satisfaction, Rolling Stones (2)
July '65: California Girls, Beach Boys (72)
July '65: Help, Beatles (29)
Sept. '65: Yesterday, Beatles (13)
Dec. '65: In My Life, Beatles (23)
Dec. '65: Norwegian Wood, Beatles (83)
Mar. '66: Sloop John B, Beach Boys (214)
June '66: Rain, Beatles (469)
May '66: Paint It Black, Rolling Stones (176)
May '66: God Only Knows, Beach Boys (25)
Every one of these songs -- released during a two-year span -- is ranked among the Top 500 of all-time. Obviously there were plenty of others. The Stones, with Jagger-Richards in their formative songwriting period, had several songs during this stretch that failed to crack the 500, notably "Heart of Stone," "Last Time," "Get Off My Cloud" and "19th Nervous Breakdown." And much of their fury was yet to be unleashed.
There has been much written about the competition between the Beatles and Beach Boys, specifically the songwriting duel of Lennon-McCartney vs. Brian Wilson. The chess match really began with the Beatles' Rubber Soul album in 1965, which Wilson acknowledged as the best he'd ever heard. He responded with Pet Sounds, and in another year the Beatles released Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. It's not too surprising to scan the top of another Rolling Stone compilation, the Greatest Albums of All Time, and find:
RS TOP 5 ALBUMS
1. Sgt. Pepper, Beatles
2. Pet Sounds, Beach Boys
3. Revolver, Beatles
4. Highway 61 Revisited, Bob Dylan
5. Rubber Soul, Beatles
But was it really a competition? Probably for Wilson, who took his songwriting role very seriously. Perhaps the most telling list of all is Wilson's personal Top 10 from the RS Top 500 Songs edition. Not surprisingly his list is heavy on voices, harmony and production, but what do you make of him putting a lesser-regarded Beatles song above four of his finest compositions? Was that the ultimate compliment, or a final dig?
BRIAN WILSON'S 10 FAVORITE SONGS
1. Be My Baby, Ronettes
2. You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling, Righteous Brothers
3. Walking in the Rain, Ronettes
4. Da Doo Ron Ron, Crystals
5. River Deep -- Mountain High, Ike and Tina Turner
6. She's Leaving Home, Beatles
7. California Girls, Beach Boys
8. Good Vibrations, Beach Boys
9. I Get Around, Beach Boys
10. Surfer Girl, Beach Boys
WHAT A STRETCH
May '64: Don't Worry Baby, Beach Boys (178)
July '64: Hard Day's Night, Beatles (154)
April '65: Ticket To Ride, Beatles (394)
May '65: Satisfaction, Rolling Stones (2)
July '65: California Girls, Beach Boys (72)
July '65: Help, Beatles (29)
Sept. '65: Yesterday, Beatles (13)
Dec. '65: In My Life, Beatles (23)
Dec. '65: Norwegian Wood, Beatles (83)
Mar. '66: Sloop John B, Beach Boys (214)
June '66: Rain, Beatles (469)
May '66: Paint It Black, Rolling Stones (176)
May '66: God Only Knows, Beach Boys (25)
Every one of these songs -- released during a two-year span -- is ranked among the Top 500 of all-time. Obviously there were plenty of others. The Stones, with Jagger-Richards in their formative songwriting period, had several songs during this stretch that failed to crack the 500, notably "Heart of Stone," "Last Time," "Get Off My Cloud" and "19th Nervous Breakdown." And much of their fury was yet to be unleashed.
There has been much written about the competition between the Beatles and Beach Boys, specifically the songwriting duel of Lennon-McCartney vs. Brian Wilson. The chess match really began with the Beatles' Rubber Soul album in 1965, which Wilson acknowledged as the best he'd ever heard. He responded with Pet Sounds, and in another year the Beatles released Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. It's not too surprising to scan the top of another Rolling Stone compilation, the Greatest Albums of All Time, and find:
RS TOP 5 ALBUMS
1. Sgt. Pepper, Beatles
2. Pet Sounds, Beach Boys
3. Revolver, Beatles
4. Highway 61 Revisited, Bob Dylan
5. Rubber Soul, Beatles
But was it really a competition? Probably for Wilson, who took his songwriting role very seriously. Perhaps the most telling list of all is Wilson's personal Top 10 from the RS Top 500 Songs edition. Not surprisingly his list is heavy on voices, harmony and production, but what do you make of him putting a lesser-regarded Beatles song above four of his finest compositions? Was that the ultimate compliment, or a final dig?
BRIAN WILSON'S 10 FAVORITE SONGS
1. Be My Baby, Ronettes
2. You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling, Righteous Brothers
3. Walking in the Rain, Ronettes
4. Da Doo Ron Ron, Crystals
5. River Deep -- Mountain High, Ike and Tina Turner
6. She's Leaving Home, Beatles
7. California Girls, Beach Boys
8. Good Vibrations, Beach Boys
9. I Get Around, Beach Boys
10. Surfer Girl, Beach Boys
Friday, June 11, 2010
We hear the train
I was born by the railroad tracks
Well the train whistle wailed and I wailed right back...
I heard the train a'comin' this morning just before dawn (Amtrak to Chicago?) and it got me to thinking more about Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Songs of All Time. And, well, a lot of other stuff as well. Mostly random thoughts because there isn't much time this morning and, really, don't most of our thoughts come to us willly-nilly this way?
You don't hear trains much in the city, either because there aren't many running any more or there's so much other offending noise, what with buses and traffic and emergency vehicle sirens, that it's not easy to isolate the sound. Or maybe they just sneak through while we're sleeping.
The old Green Bay & Western, now that train never sneaked through Whitehall no matter when it was rolling through. My family lived just two blocks from the tracks -- nearly everybody in a small town lives no farther than two blocks from the tracks -- and our house would shake when the train rumbled over those tracks. I don't remember enjoying the distruption all that much at the time, but I often wondered where it was heading and what was loaded in those box cars. And the whistle, well I do miss that whistle ...
I thought about that this morning before the alarm went off. That, and where is Johnny Cash on the Rolling Stone list? Do you think "Folsom Prison Blues" is the sort of song that might belong there? I certainly do. As Jay-Z wrote in his introduction: "When you hear a great song, you can think of where you were when you first heard it, the sounds, the smells. (Charles may have been hitting on this when he commented on "The Message" -- the song that ranks No. 51 but I can't seem to recall.) It takes the emotions of a moment and holds it for years to come. It transcends time."
Now Jay-Z's not really writing anything here that we haven't already said ourselves many times in our own conversations about music. And if you believe the premise, then you can make a case for listing any damn song you like that has moved you in your lifetime. So everybody's Top 500 is going to be decidedly different, tilted by our likes and dislikes, where we are in our lives at the moment, and a few circumstances that come to bear in the processing of it all. And every list is going to change every time we embrace a new wonder (or every six years, in the case of Rolling Stone.)
But back to Johnny Cash and "Folsom Prison Blues." The song DOES make the list, at No. 163, sandwiched between Public Enemy's "Bring the Noise" and Ray Charles' "I Can't Stop Loving You." And there are two others, "I Walk the Line" (No. 30) and "Ring of Fire" (No. 87, and my personal favorite). So we can't harp too much on Cash.
We don't wish to harp at all. Then we get to thinking about some of the greatest songwriters we've encountered in our adult lives, artists who have truly moved the needle on our personal music dial, people like Townes Van Zant, Guy Clark, Steve Earle (whose lyrics to "I Ain't Ever Satisfied" appear above) and Lucinda Williams. Hell, let's go back a bit and include Woodie Guthrie, as well as Steve Goodman and John Prine. And not a single song by any one of them makes the RS list.
And because we're gaining perspective on this it really shouldn't bother us at all. But when that special subscription offer for Rolling Stone -- once our bible, our most trusted source of music information -- tumbled out of the issue, the choice became an easy one. No thanks. Again.
Well the train whistle wailed and I wailed right back...
I heard the train a'comin' this morning just before dawn (Amtrak to Chicago?) and it got me to thinking more about Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Songs of All Time. And, well, a lot of other stuff as well. Mostly random thoughts because there isn't much time this morning and, really, don't most of our thoughts come to us willly-nilly this way?
You don't hear trains much in the city, either because there aren't many running any more or there's so much other offending noise, what with buses and traffic and emergency vehicle sirens, that it's not easy to isolate the sound. Or maybe they just sneak through while we're sleeping.
The old Green Bay & Western, now that train never sneaked through Whitehall no matter when it was rolling through. My family lived just two blocks from the tracks -- nearly everybody in a small town lives no farther than two blocks from the tracks -- and our house would shake when the train rumbled over those tracks. I don't remember enjoying the distruption all that much at the time, but I often wondered where it was heading and what was loaded in those box cars. And the whistle, well I do miss that whistle ...
I thought about that this morning before the alarm went off. That, and where is Johnny Cash on the Rolling Stone list? Do you think "Folsom Prison Blues" is the sort of song that might belong there? I certainly do. As Jay-Z wrote in his introduction: "When you hear a great song, you can think of where you were when you first heard it, the sounds, the smells. (Charles may have been hitting on this when he commented on "The Message" -- the song that ranks No. 51 but I can't seem to recall.) It takes the emotions of a moment and holds it for years to come. It transcends time."
Now Jay-Z's not really writing anything here that we haven't already said ourselves many times in our own conversations about music. And if you believe the premise, then you can make a case for listing any damn song you like that has moved you in your lifetime. So everybody's Top 500 is going to be decidedly different, tilted by our likes and dislikes, where we are in our lives at the moment, and a few circumstances that come to bear in the processing of it all. And every list is going to change every time we embrace a new wonder (or every six years, in the case of Rolling Stone.)
But back to Johnny Cash and "Folsom Prison Blues." The song DOES make the list, at No. 163, sandwiched between Public Enemy's "Bring the Noise" and Ray Charles' "I Can't Stop Loving You." And there are two others, "I Walk the Line" (No. 30) and "Ring of Fire" (No. 87, and my personal favorite). So we can't harp too much on Cash.
We don't wish to harp at all. Then we get to thinking about some of the greatest songwriters we've encountered in our adult lives, artists who have truly moved the needle on our personal music dial, people like Townes Van Zant, Guy Clark, Steve Earle (whose lyrics to "I Ain't Ever Satisfied" appear above) and Lucinda Williams. Hell, let's go back a bit and include Woodie Guthrie, as well as Steve Goodman and John Prine. And not a single song by any one of them makes the RS list.
And because we're gaining perspective on this it really shouldn't bother us at all. But when that special subscription offer for Rolling Stone -- once our bible, our most trusted source of music information -- tumbled out of the issue, the choice became an easy one. No thanks. Again.
Thursday, June 10, 2010
Their list still sucks
We took the plunge the other day and plunked down $9.95 (suckers!) for the Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs of All Time Collectors Edition. Suckers because we knew RS had compiled pretty much the same flawed list back in 2004 but six years later found itself scrambling for a new revenue stream. If the new list is different we have yet to uncover the changes.
We knew what we were getting into when we saw the introduction was written by Jay-Z. No doubt that helped spur sales. Nothing against Jay-Z -- whoever he is -- but when did he become King of America? That's not our title, that's what RS annointed him in its latest edition on the newstands.
What we got in the deal, and you probably already picked up on this, is another chance to pick apart the once relevant music magazine. Not to mention the tax deduction. So we begin today with the Top 10 songs and the most obvious question: What in the world is Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit" doing in this group? It's possible we've asked this question before, but we'll continue to pose it until someone gives us a good answer.
1. Like a Rolling Stone, Bob Dylan, 1965
2. (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction, Rolling Stones, 1965
3. Imagine, John Lennon, 1971
4. What's Going On, Marvin Gaye, 1971
5. Respect, Aretha Franklin, 1967
6. Good Vibrations, Beach Boys, 1966
7. Johnny B. Goode, Chuck Berry, 1958
8. Hey Jude, Beatles, 1968
9. Smells Like Teen Spirit, Nirvana, 1991
10. What'd I Say, Ray Charles, 1959
The Beatles barely edged out Kurt Cobain! They had the most songs on the list (23) but managed only one in the Top 10, and that one ranked below songs by two contemporary rivals, the Rolling Stones and Beach Boys.
We actually have something good to say about the Special Collectors Edition, and we'll say it as soon as we get over Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five having the 51st Greatest Song of All Time.
We knew what we were getting into when we saw the introduction was written by Jay-Z. No doubt that helped spur sales. Nothing against Jay-Z -- whoever he is -- but when did he become King of America? That's not our title, that's what RS annointed him in its latest edition on the newstands.
What we got in the deal, and you probably already picked up on this, is another chance to pick apart the once relevant music magazine. Not to mention the tax deduction. So we begin today with the Top 10 songs and the most obvious question: What in the world is Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit" doing in this group? It's possible we've asked this question before, but we'll continue to pose it until someone gives us a good answer.
1. Like a Rolling Stone, Bob Dylan, 1965
2. (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction, Rolling Stones, 1965
3. Imagine, John Lennon, 1971
4. What's Going On, Marvin Gaye, 1971
5. Respect, Aretha Franklin, 1967
6. Good Vibrations, Beach Boys, 1966
7. Johnny B. Goode, Chuck Berry, 1958
8. Hey Jude, Beatles, 1968
9. Smells Like Teen Spirit, Nirvana, 1991
10. What'd I Say, Ray Charles, 1959
The Beatles barely edged out Kurt Cobain! They had the most songs on the list (23) but managed only one in the Top 10, and that one ranked below songs by two contemporary rivals, the Rolling Stones and Beach Boys.
We actually have something good to say about the Special Collectors Edition, and we'll say it as soon as we get over Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five having the 51st Greatest Song of All Time.
Wednesday, June 9, 2010
Hey Porter, thanks for that song
Thank you, Cole Porter, for writing one of the greatest songs our ears have ever cozied up to. We're not sure why you always said you needed the sheet music to play it. It was your song, after all. You reportedly wrote it in the bar at the Ritz in Paris. Come to think of it, maybe that's why you didn't remember it.
You wrote so many incredible songs it probably would have been difficult for you to pick a personal favorite. Not a problem for us. We're going to call it one of the best tunes of the Swing Era, right up there with "Take the A Train" and "In the Mood." Yes sir, "Begin the Beguine" was and still is a sweetheart of a song.
Scores of artists have covered it, even rockers like Pete Townshend and Sheryl Crow, but by far our favorite is the 1938 recording that catapulted Artie Shaw and his Orchestra to stardom. We never paid much attention to the lyrics, even when Ella Fitzgerald was singing the song. We just wanted to hear Artie's clarinet. And we still do. Here's hoping you do too.
It's hard to believe you've been gone for 64 years now. That's right, you would have been 119 years old today. We read somewhere that you weren't all that enamored by "Begin the Beguine," and when you finally ran into Artie Shaw, who had become a big star because of your song, you gave him the ultimate compliment by calling him your "collaborator." And Artie asked if that meant he should get half the royalties.
And we think he probably should have. It was Shaw who insisted that Bluebird allow him to record the song, even if it was as a B side to "Indian Love Call." The thing about B sides is they're only a flip away. Listeners will decide if they're worth it, and listeners in this case decided it was the most popular song of 1938. We're ready to take up ballroom dancing every time we hear it.
You wrote so many incredible songs it probably would have been difficult for you to pick a personal favorite. Not a problem for us. We're going to call it one of the best tunes of the Swing Era, right up there with "Take the A Train" and "In the Mood." Yes sir, "Begin the Beguine" was and still is a sweetheart of a song.
Scores of artists have covered it, even rockers like Pete Townshend and Sheryl Crow, but by far our favorite is the 1938 recording that catapulted Artie Shaw and his Orchestra to stardom. We never paid much attention to the lyrics, even when Ella Fitzgerald was singing the song. We just wanted to hear Artie's clarinet. And we still do. Here's hoping you do too.
It's hard to believe you've been gone for 64 years now. That's right, you would have been 119 years old today. We read somewhere that you weren't all that enamored by "Begin the Beguine," and when you finally ran into Artie Shaw, who had become a big star because of your song, you gave him the ultimate compliment by calling him your "collaborator." And Artie asked if that meant he should get half the royalties.
And we think he probably should have. It was Shaw who insisted that Bluebird allow him to record the song, even if it was as a B side to "Indian Love Call." The thing about B sides is they're only a flip away. Listeners will decide if they're worth it, and listeners in this case decided it was the most popular song of 1938. We're ready to take up ballroom dancing every time we hear it.
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
Shuffle off to Bozland
Lido missed the boat that day he left the shack
But that was all he missed and he ain't comin' back
What has become of Boz Scaggs? We can't help but wonder because it's his birthday today and he isn't getting any younger. "Lido Shuffle" was one of the Bozman's most popular singles and one of our favorites until we discovered the song had absolutely no connection to Lido Key.
Reminds us of a friend who was walking his dog at sunset near DeSoto Point in Bradenton and came upon a photo shoot for Playboy. This is a true story. Like most dogs, the golden retreiver was an inquisitive sort. So was our friend, for that matter. Wait, we can't tell that story here! Ask about it sometime and we'll give you the lowdown. Speaking of which, "Lowdown" was Scaggs' highest charting single (No. 3). There's a time for everything, and 1976 must have been the right time to release the album Silk Degrees, on which both songs appear. But if pressed to name our favorite, it would be Middle Man, which followed two years later and included "JoJo" and "Breakdown Dead Ahead."
Happy sixto-sixto, Bozman, wherever you are. And many more to you and the rest of our Birthday Band:
Nancy Sinatra (1940): Singer
These Boots Are Made For Walkin’, Somethin’ Stupid (w/ Frank), Jackson (w/Lee Hazelwood)
Chuck Negron (1942): Singer, Three Dog Night
Joy to the World, One, Easy to Be Hard, Eli’s Coming, Mama Told Me Not to Come
Boz Scaggs (1944): Musician/singer
Lowdown, Lido Shuffle, Miss Sun, Look What You’ve Done to Me
Mick Box (1947): Guitar, Uriah Heep
Gypsy, Salisbury, July Morning, Easy Livin’
Bonnie Tyler (1951): Singer
Total Eclipse of the Heart, It’s a Heartache
But that was all he missed and he ain't comin' back
What has become of Boz Scaggs? We can't help but wonder because it's his birthday today and he isn't getting any younger. "Lido Shuffle" was one of the Bozman's most popular singles and one of our favorites until we discovered the song had absolutely no connection to Lido Key.
Reminds us of a friend who was walking his dog at sunset near DeSoto Point in Bradenton and came upon a photo shoot for Playboy. This is a true story. Like most dogs, the golden retreiver was an inquisitive sort. So was our friend, for that matter. Wait, we can't tell that story here! Ask about it sometime and we'll give you the lowdown. Speaking of which, "Lowdown" was Scaggs' highest charting single (No. 3). There's a time for everything, and 1976 must have been the right time to release the album Silk Degrees, on which both songs appear. But if pressed to name our favorite, it would be Middle Man, which followed two years later and included "JoJo" and "Breakdown Dead Ahead."
Happy sixto-sixto, Bozman, wherever you are. And many more to you and the rest of our Birthday Band:
Nancy Sinatra (1940): Singer
These Boots Are Made For Walkin’, Somethin’ Stupid (w/ Frank), Jackson (w/Lee Hazelwood)
Chuck Negron (1942): Singer, Three Dog Night
Joy to the World, One, Easy to Be Hard, Eli’s Coming, Mama Told Me Not to Come
Boz Scaggs (1944): Musician/singer
Lowdown, Lido Shuffle, Miss Sun, Look What You’ve Done to Me
Mick Box (1947): Guitar, Uriah Heep
Gypsy, Salisbury, July Morning, Easy Livin’
Bonnie Tyler (1951): Singer
Total Eclipse of the Heart, It’s a Heartache
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




